Give Back Cupcake

$30 per dozen

These cupcakes are named in honor of Vicki’s mom, Janice “Janny” Bradtmueller and Deb’s dad, John Schumacher both of whom lost their battle with cancer. During their battle they received assistance from Cancer Services of NE Indiana. For every dozen purchased, Best Friends Bakery will give a donation back to the Cancer Services.

  • Janny’s Jar Cake a butter pound cake baked in a 4 oz. jelly jar and infused and topped with a rich butter sauce. Named in honor of Vicki’s mother

  • Hoosier Hawkeye a rich chocolate butter cake baked in a 4 oz. jelly jar, infused with a butter sauce and topped with a whipped peanut butter ganache. Named in honor of Deb’s father who was born and raised in Iowa, home of the Hawkeyes he later moved to Indiana and became a fan of the Hoosier state.

Basic Flavors

$20 per dozen

  • Vanilla with your choice of icing flavor or color

  • Chocolate with your choice of icing flavor or color

  • Lemon with your choice of icing flavor or color

  • Strawberry with your choice of icing flavor or color

  • Spice with your choice of icing flavor or color

  • Carrot with cream cheese icing

  • Red Velvet with cream cheese icing

  • Birthday Classic a confetti cupcake topped with vanilla buttercream and sprinkles

  • Snickerdoodle the taste of the cookie all wrapped into a cupcake and sprinkled with cinnamon and sugar

  • White Wedding Cake a traditional white wedding cake with a hint of almond in cupcake form

  • Marbled Marble a marble cupcake with marbled icing

  • Mocha a coffee infused chocolate cupcake with mocha icing

  • Raspberry or Strawberry Lemonade your choice of berry cupcake with lemon frosting and an optional drinking straw

  • Margarita margarita flavored cupcake, lime frosting topped with fresh lime and coarse sea salt

  • Dreamsicle orange cupcake with marshmallow cream frosting

  • Pina Colada pineapple cupcake with a hint of rum, vanilla frosting and topped with coconut

  • Tropical Twist a pineapple cupcake with a lime frosting

    Specialty Flavors

    $25 per dozen

  • Amish Peanut Butter a vanilla cupcake with marshmallow filling a peanut butter icing

  • Neopolitan a vanilla cupcake, strawberry filling and chocolate frosting

  • Twinkie a french vanilla cupcake with marshmallow filling and marshmallow buttercream icing

  • Black Forest a chocolate cupcake with cherry filling and a whipped cream frosting

  • Camo a chocolate, milk chocolate and white cupcake with camo icing

  • Chocolate Dipped Strawberry a chocolate cupcake with strawberry filling and chocolate icing

  • Chocolate Hazelnut hazelnuts baked inside a chocolate cupcake with a chocolate hazelnut frosting and topped with more hazelnuts

  • Chocolate Peanut Butter a peanut butter filled chocolate cupcake topped with a chocolate buttercream

    and chocolate morsel

  • Everything a peanut butter filled chocolate cupcake with a caramel icing and garnished with pretzel, nuts and mini chocolate chips

  • Malted Milk a chocolate malted cupcake with chocolate malt frosting and topped with malted milk ball pieces

  • Right Side Upside Down pineapple cupcake with whipped cream frosting and a maraschino cherry

  • Rootbeer Float a root beer flavored chocolate cupcake with marshmallow buttercream, sprinkles and an optional drinking straw

  • Cookies and Cream chocolate cupcake with chocolate sandwich cookies pieces baked inside and topped with a cookies and cream frosting and a mini chocolate sandwich cookie

  • Caramel Apple a caramel cupcake with apple filling and caramel icing

  • Bananas Foster a caramel cupcake with caramel banana filling with a vanilla buttercream a caramel drizzle

  • Lemon Blueberry a lemon cupcake filled with blueberries topped with lemon icing and a fresh blueberry

  • Lemon Lovers a lemon cupcake with lemon filling and lemon icing

  • Triple Strawberry strawberry cupcake, strawberry filling and strawberry icing

Signature Flavors

Includes Gluten Free

$30 per dozen

  • Yellow or Chocolate Gluten Free a gluten free cupcake with your choice of icing

  • Chocolate Bourbon a bourbon infused chocolate cupcake with a dark chocolate bourbon filling and topped with a bourbon chocolate buttercream

  • German Chocolate with the classic coconut pecan frosting garnished with a pecan

  • Salted Caramel Turtle a caramel cupcake with chocolate icing and garnished with pecan and sea salt

  • Mexican Classic chocolate cupcake spiced with cinnamon and cayenne topped with a cinnamon buttercream

    and candied peppered bacon

  • Peanut Butter Cup a peanut butter cup baked inside a chocolate cupcake, peanut butter icing and topped with a mini peanut butter cup

  • Pink Champagne a pink champagne flavored cupcake with a pink champagne icing

  • Maple Bacon a vanilla cupcake with a hint of maple topped with a maple buttercream and crisp crumbled bacon pieces

  • Chocolate Stout a stout beer infused chocolate cupcake and topped with a stout chocolate buttercream

  • Butter Rum a butter cake with pecans and coconut a hint of rum and topped with a butter rum glaze

Delivery fee is $25. NOTE: Additional fees may be added based on mileage and/or extra labor costs for setup.